Trump Carney Trade Deal: “Very Nice” but Keystone Isn’t Enough as $80B Claim Fails Fact-Check

President Donald Trump says the United States and Canada are working on a “fair” trade deal — but he made clear on Friday that Prime Minister Mark Carney’s offer on a pipeline is not enough on its own. Speaking at a White House news conference after returning from a trip to Asia, Trump said: “While more work remains to be done with Canada, Prime Minister Carney was very nice. He met me. We spent a little time talking, but Canada has been ripping us off for many, many years, and it’s time to stop.”

ताजे अपडेट पाने के लिये हमारे ग्रुप को ज्वाइन करें Join Now

“One of the things he wants to do is build a Keystone pipeline for us, and we like that. But, you know, we’ve got to do a lot more than that,” Trump added. The two leaders met briefly on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen, China, on 18 November. Carney told the New York Times’ DealBook summit the same day that the two countries had made some progress but “we’re not there yet” on putting an agreement on paper. His office said they discussed “the work underway to reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement that would create good jobs, boost affordability, and fully respect Canada’s languages, culture, and sovereignty”, and agreed to stay in close contact. As of Friday evening, Ottawa had not publicly responded to Trump’s remarks.

The $80 billion claim does not add up

Trump repeated his long-running complaint about the trade gap, putting the US deficit with Canada at “about an $80 billion” figure and adding: “When it’s down to zero, come over and let’s start talking.” His own administration’s figures tell a smaller story. The Office of the US Trade Representative records the 2025 US goods deficit with Canada at $48.3 billion — exports of $333.6 billion against imports of $381.9 billion — down 21% from 2024. The US also runs a $27.7 billion surplus in services with Canada, so the combined goods-and-services deficit is only about $20.6 billion. Excluding energy, the US would actually run a surplus with its northern neighbour. The $80 billion figure is closer to the official number than the $200 billion Trump has often used, but it is still well above it.

What Ottawa wants is an interim arrangement by the end of the year, covering lower tariffs on steel, aluminum, autos and lumber and the full removal of the 50% tariffs imposed in August under Section 338. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc briefed Canada’s advisory committee on the plan on Thursday, but he also cautioned that the year-end target is not a hard deadline: “If it takes until January or February to get that deal, we’ll do that work.” Trump’s threatened 50% auto tariff hike for 1 January has had no formal notice filed yet. On Keystone, the original XL project was never finished and was cancelled in 2021 after President Joe Biden revoked its permit; the current proposal involves a project reusing XL infrastructure, and Trump signed a new cross-border permit in April — but no final investment decision has been made, so a revival is far from a done deal. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who appeared with Trump, said the meeting “moved the ball forward on getting to a final agreement that is good for American workers and fair to the United States of America.” For the meeting that set this up, see Carney–Trump trade deal stalls as Carney says “we’re busy”, and for the domestic backdrop, see Canada budget 2026 passes the House 162–151.